Oct 21, 2001 islam s gospel of barnabas hoax 102101 self posted on 10212001 8. Contradictions between the quran and the gospel of barnabas contradictions of the. This is a further description of the vassal who owes to his liege or padrone a portion of his crop 122. Barnabas has not met jesus ever, but this gospel of barnabas tells us that not that they talked to each other but also that called him barnabas, a nickname he acquired after the death of jesus. Muhammad, the prophet of islam, was in contact with jews and christians. The gospel of barnabas was obviously written as an ideal islamic gospel, setting forth a life of christ in which he is made to be the isa of the quran rather than the lord jesus christ of the christian gospels. The manuscript from which the current english translation of the gospel of barnabas was made, was originally in the possession of pope sixtus v 15891590. Nov 16, 2010 thus gospel of barnabas will neither satisfy a muslim nor a christian. Barnabas personally brought paul to the apostles and supported pauls claim to have seen jesus in a vision and to have accepted christianity. There appears to be no other trace of this work, and it is doubtful if it ever existed. The book, thought to be an authentic version of the gospel of barnabas, was confiscated during an antismuggling operation in turkeys mediterranean region in 2000. Answers of samuel green 16 about the gospel of barnabas. Introduction islam 101 jihad muhammad authority of the bible quran women under islam.
His name joseph, and due to his devotion to the cause of jesus, the other apostles had given him the surname of barnabas. He who believes it, can neither be a true muslim, nor a true christian. Understanding some muslim misunderstandings answering islam. They try proving muhammad is mentioned in the bible and so is mecca but without any success. The gospel of barnabas contradicts certain principles of islam. Facts about other gospels veracity in the gospel v 286 10. How the gospel of barnabas appendix i 274 survived 6. The gospel of barnabas is evidenced to be a late forgery, claiming to have been written by the apostle barnabas but proactively promoting islam. Aug 05, 2010 muslims believe that islam was the religion which was practised by all the prophets abraham, david, moses, solomon, jonah and others.
But as it so hopelessly contradicts both the quran and the bible on the fact that jesus was the messiah and does this so often and. The spurious gospel in islamic apologetics by john gilchrist the claim that the gospel of barnabas is the true gospel. If muhammad really was foretold in the gospel there would be no need for muslims to rewrite the gospel with muhammad now foretold in it. One of the oldest gospels ever found was the gospel of barnabas one found in jesuss language syriac aramiac dating back to 50ad older then any gospel in. The quran, the holy book of islam, frequently refers to the holy books of the jews and christians. Muslim interest in the socalled gospel of barnabas. In this short video, ahmed deedat and zakir naik answer other muslims who ask them to comment on the gospel of barnabas. Although they will deny this the actions of muslims shows they are desperate trying to prove to the world islam is the true religion and the quran is the only true word of god. As we discussed at length and illustrated with the help of a few examples in the first part of our analysis, pseudo barnabas supposed that maintaining the style of the canonical gospels and changing only their content through the insertion of some basic islamic teachings would gain his forgery credibility, but. The aim of these books is to try to convince people that jesus was a muslim and predicted the coming of muhammad. The other strange thing is that barnabas in this text supports the retention of circumcision and other jewish practises.
It is interesting that muslims are not aware that this book of barnabas contradicts the quran in several places. You can read the gospel of barnabas in english online at. Pay special attention to chapters 4,5, 8, 9, and appendix 5. The gospel of barnabas contradicts certain principles of islam the gospel of barnabas, in many respects, is in harmony with the principles of islam, but it contradicts some. Whenever muslims conquered territory they turned churches into mosques. Fragments of it survive in the received canonical gospels and in some others, of which traces survive e. Two manuscripts are known to have existed, both dated to the late 16th or early 17th centuries, with one written in italian and the other in spanish, its text surviving only in a partial 18thcentury transcript. Josh mcdowell, the new evidence that demands a verdict nashville. Contradictions between the quran and the gospel of barnabas. These false gospels are contributing proof that muhammad is not foretold in the bible and that this claim of. Islam bismillah was salamu 3ala rasoolillah as salamu 3ala man atabaa3 al hudaa wa rahmat allahee wa barakatuhu muslims are in the trend lately of insulting islam and the entire ummah by quoting from. The gospel of barnabas is a forgery jesus christ vs. Aug 22, 2009 to begin with, we can make the following dogmatic statements. The gospel of barnabas, until now, is the only eyewitness account of the life and mission of jesus.
Topics barnabas, gospel collection opensource language english. How muslims understand gospel of barnabas christians. Origins and sources of the gospel of barnabas jesus to the muslims 1979. He had a friend, a monk called fra marino, who became very interested in the gospel of barnabas after reading the writings of iraneus, who quoted from it extensively. Iranaeus 200 wrote in support of pure monotheism and opposed paul for injecting into christianity doctrines of the pagan roman religion and platonic philosophy. If these writings were not more authentic than the four present gospels, they were of equal authenticity. This manuscript was written in italian and supplied with footnotes in poor arabic. The gospel of barnabas is promoted by muslims as an original gospel written by the man named barnabas1 who it is claimed was a disciple of jesus p. Therefore, credulity reigns when muslims accept the existence of an antipauline work by irenaeus, when such a work is based on a single medieval report, is otherwise never mentioned in. Should muslims read the gospel of barnabas as the true story of isa. One of the earliest caliphs declared the furthest mosque 60 miles away fr medina as the temple mount in jerusalem which they captured in 637 ad and had no mosque then. I thought of islam as a faith with such high ideals that i did not consider myself worthy of the name muslim but i wholeheartedly believed that islam was gods last and most perfect religion for all mankind, based on gods final revelation, the quran, and the prophet muhammad, gods seal of prophethood. Facsimile of the original title page the gospel of barnabas.
While some muslims have presented the gospel of barnabas as proof of the. Contradictions between the quran and the gospel of barnabas contradictions of the gob with itself. Gospel of barnabas will cause christianitys collapse. The gospel of barnabas highly recommended article islam. Beliefs about jesus vary widely between christians and muslims because their sources differ. Some of them are still available such as the gospel of barnabas and the shepherd of hermas which agree with the quran. The italian manuscript was translated into english by canon lonsdale and laura ragg, and was printed and published by the oxford university press in 1907. Yusuf ali refers to it in his commentary on the quran. Origins and sources of the gospel of barnabas answering islam.
Nearly the whole edition of this english translation abruptly and mysteriously disappeared from the market. The gospel of barnabas muslims often cite the gospel of barnabas in defense of islamic teaching. It is the single gospel which, islam teaches, was revealed to jesus, and which he taught. Few things more aptly attest to the relative scholarship of islam s muftis and imams, than their suggestion that the socalled gospel of barnabas was left out of the new testament because it is the only true gospel, as opposed to the inspired gospel witness records of matthew, mark, luke and john the whole subect of which they must of course deny. An indepth, 20hour series on the christian response to the challenge of islam topics. Gospel of barnabas and islam thoughts and truth from the. That is, it is a life of jesus purportedly written by a firsthand observer that is at variance with the pictures presented in the bible.
Full text of gospel of barnabas and islam see other formats the foretelling of hazrat muhammad pbuh in the gospel of barnabas the gospel of barnabas is a book about the life and teachings of prophet essa may peace be upon him written by an eye witness and a close disciple namely barnabas died, 6061 ad. Jul 07, 2015 he only mentions barnabas on seven occasions and never quotes from or even mentions a gospel of barnabas ah 3. The authors, a christian apologist and a former muslim, provide apologetic answers to prepare christians for ministry in the islamic context. Evidence reveals that the gospel of barnabas was most likely written by a fifteenthcentury european who wrote inaccurately about the life of jesus. After reading a scary claim that a real gospel was suppressed for the. In trying to learn about islam, i kept running across a socalled gospel of barnabas, used by muslims to prove mohammed was in the bible and jesus wasnt really crucified.
Muslims often cite the gospel of barnabas in defense of islamic teaching. Contradictions in the gospel of barnabas there are plenty of contradictions between the gospel of barnabas gob and the bible, between the gob and the quran some are documented here, but on this page we want to document passages where the gospel of barnabas contradicts itself. Answering islam will answer all of your most basic questions about islam and help you understand not only the news but also the threat that islam poses to christianity and the west. Muhammad the quran for research purposes islam s low view of women by david wood. The gospel of barnabas, in many respects, is in harmony with the principles of islam, but it contradicts some. The gospel of barnabas arabic bible outreach ministry.
A paper written to prove the authenticity of some key portions of the existing gospel of barnabas. No historical record whatsoever exists to show what sort of book it was or what it taught. Why muslims shouldnt use it examines the common assumptions muslims make about the gob. Why did the christians hide the gospel of barnabas.
Allah taala repeatedly reminds the people of the book jews and christians by delivering clear messages in holy quran. The writer of the gospel of barnabas represents to us mary, martha, and lazarus as feudal lords, in whose hands was the proprietorship of whole villages 194. A christian would say that he rejects the gospel of barnabas because it is not written by barnabas but by a muslim who sneaked it into the vatican library where it was found on the popes desks, shelves etc. The authors of the gospel of barnabas and the gospel according to islam have both rewritten the biblical gospel to make it agree with the quran. Muslims believe that islam was the religion which was practised by all the prophets abraham, david, moses, solomon, jonah and others. Sale, who in his translation of the koran, notices this gospel, likewise had a ms. This text for the epistle of barnabas comes from the early church fathers, volume 1, pages 7149, which is in public domain. One of their supposed proof is the gospel of barnabas. Jun 20, 20 one of the oldest gospels ever found was the gospel of barnabas one found in jesuss language syriac aramiac dating back to 50ad older then any gospel in the new testament and about the same time. No one can believe this gospel and believe the holy bible at the same time. The gospel of barnabas answering islam, a christian.
As regards the gospel of barnabas itself, there is no question that it is a medieval forgery. Furthermore, no one can believe the gospel of barnabas and believe the quran at the same time. There are plenty of contradictions between the gospel of barnabas gob and the bible, between the gob and the quran some are documented here, but on this page we want to document passages where the gospel of barnabas contradicts itself. A gospel of barnabas is mentioned in the gelasian decree and in the catalogue of the sixty books see ntap. The gospel of barnabas is a book depicting the life of jesus, which claims to be by the biblical barnabas who in this work is one of the twelve apostles. The gospel of barnabas is a book depicting the life of jesus, which claims to be by the biblical. Answering islam helps the christian reader by helping him to understand why christians reject islam and how christians can defend christianity against islam. How muslims understand gospel of barnabas christians should. The gospel of barnabas an islamic fake by jason burns. An unknown figure of the medieval period that had his peculiar reasons to betray his christian faith decided to devise a new gospel compatible with the islamic creed and tradition and attributed his forgery to the apostle barnabas, naming his fake writing the gospel of barnabas.
Muslims think of jesus as a prophet who is reputed to have done miracles, but most of them have no knowledge of most of his life and. The italian manuscript of the gob sports a 16 th century. A christian will be surprised to hear for the first time that there are supposed prophecies to muhammad in the. Should muslims read the gospel of barnabas as the true story. There is a barnabas mentioned in galatians and acts of the new testament who had a ministry with the other apostles, however, this could not be the same barnabas because as with islam the author of this late gospel emphatically denied many core. This early reference might have been to one of the other books named after the apostle barnabas.
I also coauthored a book with norman geisler, a prominent christian philosopher, with the title answering islam. The muslim evidence for the antiquity of the gospel of barnabas 6. We should make best use of those ayahs verses as these are excellent for dawah originated by the creator allah. Lonsdale and laura ragg london, 1907 the gospel of barnabas is an apocryphal gospel.
The gospel of barnabas, popular muslim accusations against the new testament, islam and violence. There were numerous apocryphal gospels, epistles and other forgeries similar in style to the authentic new testament scriptures that were rejected by the council of nicaea in 325 ad and in the subsequent decretum gelasianum of which one was titled the gospel of barnabas. For more videos on the subject of islam from a christian perspective please type larry wessels islam in the youtube search box see particularly our 10 hour series entitled, answering islam. Eg,a typical contradiction between the quran and the book of barnabas is found in the statement in the gospel of barnabas about the angels of god on the last days before the great judgment. Thus they claim it was written by a jewish man in the 1st century a. The gospel of barnabas was accepted as a canonical gospel in the churches of alexandria till 325 c. The gospel of barnabas is promoted by muslims as an original gospel written by the man named barnabas 1 who it is claimed was a disciple of jesus p. Suzanne haneef, in her annotated bibliography on islam, highly recommends it, saying, within it one finds the living jesus portrayed far more vividly and in character with the mission with.
724 939 549 1053 132 635 127 761 43 1092 356 758 1218 886 288 817 1230 1058 308 829 1367 1229 352 232 673 1425 505 1145 360 920 314 1424 266