Its a notion that takes some growing used to, but pauline kael makes her case persuasively. In march, new yorker critic pauline kael had taken the. The films he made through his company included brewster mccloud. The shrewdest thing to say about pauline kael beyond recognising that she. Shelley duvall was born on the 7th july 1949, in houston, texas usa, and is a film and television actress, the winner of an lafca award, cannes film festival award as well as peabody award. Would you go to a movie that was hailed as a masterpiece. She was one of the most influential american film critics of her era. Pauline kael won the national book award for her film criticism in 1974. How hollywood seduced and abandoned critic pauline kael. In writing this book, jan stuart enjoyed the benefit of full cooperation from altman, who sat for many hours of interviews, as well as most of the motley. Brewster mccloud 1970, mixing broad counterculture satire and fairytale, lost him much of the credit mash had won. In this, he says he was influenced by christopher laschs book, the. It certainly wasnt any less unusual for the era in which it was made except that the films quirky tone that shifted. Stone based on their play, directed by robert altman and starring philip baker hall as former president richard m.
Brewster mccloud 1970 movie clip did you see that grenade. If such a catastrophe has indeed occurred, i disclaim all responsibility. Sally kellerman is his birdmother, who deserts him when he loses his virginity. Secret honor is a 1984 film written by donald freed and arnold m. Brewster mccloud robert altman, 1970 some came running. The unstructured brewster mccloud seems more a case of director altman flexing his style for a cinematic fingerpainting exercise. Mar 29, 1989 pauline kael was an american film critic who wrote for the new yorker magazine from 1968 to 1991. Clearly kael s favourite filmmaker of the early 70s. Comedy 101 min, rated r, color, available on videocassette robert. Nov 30, 2016 deep from the annals of my vhs archive. Its one reason i ruffled so many feathers to continue the chickenfarm trope by my book on poetry, break, blow, burn, which promoted the beat style and. Boston, 1971, that he was a selfaggrandizing egotist who managed to squander his prodigious talent while refusing to give credit to the work of others.
Harold and maude 1971 a box office failure upon its initial release in 1971 which slowly but surely amassed a global cult following, harold and maude 1971 is one of those cinematic oddities that is hard to imagine being made within the confines of todays film industry. And then she names the three directors she feels are making the most exciting movies right now. Pauline kael has 26 books on goodreads with 9257 ratings. Brewster mccloud warner archive collection 1970 color 2. Why robert altmans brilliant nashville never had a. Mash was followed by brewster mccloud, and mccabe and mrs miller has now been followed by images. Miller, the long goodbye, 3 women, and short cuts, there would be no doubt about his ultimate importance.
According to jan stuart, in his superbly illuminating book the. June 19, 1919 september 3, 2001 was an american film critic who wrote for the new yorker magazine from 1968 to 1991. The screenplay by altman and brian mckay is based on the 1959 novel mccabe by edmund naughton. End of the road doesnt come close to working but its absolutely worth watching.
He is helped by his comely and enigmatic fairy godmother, played by sally kellerman, as he becomes a suspect in a series of murders. With woody allen, lili anolik, alec baldwin, carol baum. The movie starts from a trash novel that is generally considered gripping and compulsively readable, though maybe because movies more than satisfy my appetite for trash i found it unreadable. In 1969 she had a job selling cosmetics at foleys when, at a party, she met director robert altman, who was in town to film brewster mccloud. There is a kind of ferocious tenacity about the way she acts on this conviction, a fanaticism about what a film is capable of being, that makes movie executives cringe in the privacy of their corporate sanctuaries and publicists worry about who shes going to rend asunder next. For me the tipoff is the curtaincall finish borrowed from federico fellinis 8. If ever there was a great example of how the best popular movies come out of a merger of commerce and art, the godfather is it. She is so influential that even people who dont know her probably use a lot of her writing style in their film criticism. Pauline kael in the new yorker otto preminger the human factor 1979 unfortunately, preminger stages it all as if he was just trying to get all the actors through their line readings in under two hours, allowing no breathing room or time for character nuance in.
It was 40 years ago this month that robert altmans masterpiece nashville hit screens, but the arrival hadnt come unannounced. But while its possible to regard the subtitle of pauline kael. The first time around, things went a little differently. Miller is a 1971 american revisionist western film directed by robert altman, and starring warren beatty and julie christie. In march, new yorker critic pauline kael had taken the extraordinary step of. A life, resurrects all the old debates, controversies, and feuds from a time when it. May 04, 2014 pauline kael is the guest on this episode of the writers workshop, filmed at the university of south carolina on feb. I never knew pauline but was in her presence twice, first at a luncheon for. Why warren beattys attack on pauline kael failed the guardian. Neglected by warners, it was dismissed until pauline kael persuaded. Costumed like wheres waldo, young brewster mccloud bud cort. The fact is altman is dumping square conventions that dont work anymore.
A portrait of the work and life of controversial film critic pauline kael, and her battle to achieve success and influence in the 20th century movie business. Her overview of the film is that it is a deeply immoral one with manipulative skills and fascist potential 421. We get the sense of a live intelligence, rushing things ahead on. Moreover, duvall also worked as a producer, singer, writer and comedian, and as a producer, she was nominated for an. Martin scorsese, who grew up in new yorks little italy with a. The strawberry statement, brewster mccloud, drive, he said, two. It was, by most accounts, a hopelessly boring, muddled, pretentious, mess of a movie, with altmans tricks of muddy sound and muddy lenses or in this case, heavily ofiltered lenses, as if were peering through an iced. There are 2,846 in all, ranging from early silents to the early 1990s, when kael retired. It concerns a young recluse bud cort, as the title character who lives in a fallout shelter of the houston astrodome, where he is building a pair of wings so he can fly. With zabriskie point, antonioni offered an explosive look at america. With dirty harry she insists that violence has rarely been presented with such righteous relish abrahams 421. A life in the dark, by brian kellow, features editor for opera news and author of ethel merman. Pauline kael wants people to go to the movies the stacks. Kathryn altman, who died in 2016, coauthored a book about altman that was.
Why robert altmans brilliant nashville never had a sequel. Sep 05, 2001 pauline kael was small, wiry and as energetic as a terrier. Occasionally, a particularly rich period in one of the arts coincides with a. Mash was followed by brewster mccloud, and mccabe and mrs miller. Mash was followed by brewster mccloud, and mccabe and mrs miller has now. Miller in the july 3, 1971 issue of the new yorker the classical story is only a thread in the story that altman is tellingthe people who drop in and out of the placea primitive mining townare not just background for mccabe.
Pauline kael is most likely the most significant name in film criticism from the past 50 years or so. The movie doesnt find a way to give us the emotional texture of the interrelationships and dependencies in the book one can probably enjoy the. This was part of a promotional film for the new yorker that also included a profile of cartoonist. Jun 05, 2015 it was 40 years ago this month that robert altmans masterpiece nashville hit screens, but the arrival hadnt come unannounced. Almost every interesting american movie in the past few years has been directed by a catholic. The job of the regular daily, weekly, or even monthly critic resembles the work of the serious intermittent critic, who writes only when he is asked to or genuinely moved to, in limited ways and for only a limited period of time. For a more extended discussion, see pauline kaels book reeling. Pauline kael kept his early career going when the box office receipts. In the fall of 1965, a season that brought movies as distinct as alphaville and thunderball to the screen, pauline kael came to dinner at sidney lumets apartment, in new york. As a film critic writing for the new yorker from 1967 to 1991, pauline kael changed the. Books by pauline kael author of i lost it at the movies. It seems to be trying to sum up and evaluate the whole decade of the 60s while. Pauline kael on robert altman films rate your music.
Street date july, 2010 available through the warner archive collection 24. When altman enters this phase, he goes into his own fugal version of dreamtime, which means, in practice, that he puts the audience in such a depressed state that people are fighting to stay awake even before the titles come on. Review by not pauline kael a trivial but entertaining sex comedy derived from the henry miller novel about expatriates in paris. He goes out in a new direction each time, and he scores an astonishing 50% one on, one off. Feb 03, 2010 but somehow i find the most riveting thing about this story is beattys extraordinary duel with the new yorkers legendary film critic pauline kael.
Born in petaluma, california, she was soon an avid reader and movie enthusiast, encouraged by her father, himself a film fan. Pauline kael panned, if it werent for this peculiar sense of dislocation and the embarrassment you feel for. Pauline kael s most popular book is i lost it at the movies. Bud cort title character is the driver for the 120yearold flying ace abraham wright stacy keach jr.
Without spending a lot of money but totally free to do as he pleases, robert altman comes up with a completely nonsensical fantasy loosely organized around his favorite actors of the moment. With zabriskie point, antonioni offered an explosive look. And pauline kael desperately wants people to go to the movies. By the time nashville sent her into convulsions kael had dismissed, with varying degrees of sorrow, brewster mccloud, images, and california split. I read about great directors, minor directors for years, my view of orson welles was based on pauline kael s raising kane in the citizen kane book atlantic monthly press. Nixon, a fictional account attempting to gain insight into nixons personality, life, attitudes and behavior. I havent included books which concentrate only on visual elements andor special effects. Its that quality thats so attractive about these two altman films. Inspire a love of reading with prime book box for kids discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1. Gentle brewster, who is building wings for himself, is a boy phantom of the astrodome who is also an imperiled virgina sort of mad, murderous peter pan, or rima the bird boy. The film critic for the new yorker from 1968 to 1991, she is the author of more than a dozen books on the movies. Critic pauline kael, writing about his directing style, said that altman could.
As another one of those performers, michael murphy, notes in zuckoffs endlessly engaging book, the expected thing for a director to do in the. Her negative viewpoint of this film is of particular interest because up until this movie, kael had been a consistently staunch altman ally. How robert altman blew up the rule book the telegraph. Brewster mccloud is a 1970 american experimental comedy film directed by robert altman. Other than that, i struggled with the book so much so that i couldnt finish it, and the film even though its only under an hour and a half, i struggled with that too. On quintet, robert altmans dystopian nightmare from 1979. That struck me when i first stumbled on her books in a university. The whole thing is amorphous and rather silly, but its clearly a trial run for some of the effects that altman brings off in nashville. America singing the current the criterion collection. Quintet endured an awful reception upon its release, and the few who actually saw it in 1979 basically ran away from it as quickly as they could. In 1979, at the invitation of warren beatty, she came to hollywood to work in the movie business.
I think its also the only one of her books to feature her picture on the cover if we saw her before, she was always on the back. Brewster mccloud is just as densely packed with words and action, and you keep thinking youre missing things. For a more extended discussion, see pauline kaels book i lost it at the movies. For a more extended discussion, see pauline kael s book i lost it at the movies. Brewster mccloud 1970 robert altmans film was shot in houston. Robert bernard altman was an american film director, screenwriter, and producer. One of the things about mash was that people wanted to see it a second time. May 10, 2016 kael does not care for justified violence in films in general.
Robert altmans brewster mccloud 1970 it isnt on dvd yet, there are still a few laser discs of it floating around, but on monday, august 27th, you can see robert altmans brewster mccloud 1970 the way it was supposed to be seen. Pauline kael was a film critic for the new yorker from 1967 to 1991, as well as the author of several books, including i lost it at the movies and for keeps. He promptly cast her as a randy astrodome tour guide. Without intending to, i found myself rereading about half the book over the. Comedy 101 min, rated r, color, available on videocassette robert altmans film was shot in houston. Pauline kael, altmans most important critic, captured his. In what has inspired a number of debates, pauline kael truly disliked the movie. Her odd dismissal of 3 women seemed to curse this extraordinary surrealistic movie. Pauline kaels most popular book is i lost it at the movies. Shelley duvall, michael murphy, sally kellerman, bud cort. I have also excluded short works of 100 pages or so such as the bfi film classics series.
652 610 192 284 831 541 973 841 1267 1234 1423 1371 1369 845 1220 305 1448 1535 982 1447 440 1263 655 1229 1310 495 380 1325 877 79